WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

Norma Joy's picture

Was this contest on the up and up? It really doesn't seem that way. To be objective I will not tell who I was rooting for.

I will just say let's look at a few disturbing facts.

The deadline for entries? Changed.

The way the voting was done? Changed. (In the middle it went from stars to bars) Did you notice? And sometimes that didn't work at all.

The sending of the top 3 to Chris Martin? Changed!!!!

They picked 2 other groups to send. How did they pick the other two and why? There was a rumor that the voting was close. Really?

Did everyone else stay up after midnight like I did?

Uh the voting ended at 11:59 and what I saw was "Common Thrill," followed by "The Luxury" then "Old Abram Brown" waaaaaay ahead of everyone else, by thousands of points. How was it close?! It wasn't! Not by a long shot. So who did WFNX send.

Did Chris Martin ever hear all top 3 winners you, the fans picked?

We, the listeners and the voting public want to know--

WHAT IS GOING ON!?

Sincerely,

A believer in fairplay for Coldpay.

Ronaldo's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?


I'm out getting my abs airbrushed on...leave a message

zippyzero's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

These contests definitely have a stink of backroom political bullshit (I heard that WFNX is notorious for it) but I'm glad to see that the Luxury won.

gaberollins's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

Hahahaha

Lincoln's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

Not stating who you were rooting for doesn't make you "objective", by the way. I'm not sure what it makes you.

Ronaldo's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

Lincoln wrote:
Not stating who you were rooting for doesn't make you "objective", by the way. I'm not sure what it makes you.

Right? I mean sorry you didn't win, Old Abram Brown....but....

zippyzero's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

Uh the voting ended at 11:59 and what I saw was "Common Thrill," followed by "The Luxury" then "Old Abram Brown" waaaaaay ahead of everyone else, by thousands of points. How was it close?! It wasn't! Not by a long shot. So who did WFNX send.

If what this guy is saying is true, you have to admit that's pretty messed up. I mean The Luxury is sort of local (right?) which is great and I'm glad they won just for that reason alone (I haven't had a chance to see them)...but if the shoe had been on the other foot or if it was your band that was in that situation....it would be an all out WFNX trash fest today.

Sorry, Wings, that sucks for your buddy's band... or your band or whatever.

MrPEZ's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

There was definitely some weirdness going on. But it wasn't just the Boston contest that had the rules/voting/whatever changed mid-stream. There were simultaneous contests going on in 5 different markets, and they ALL changed in the exact same fashion. So WFNX clearly had nothing to do with this. In fact, they had very little to do with the contest at all, once the 15 finalists had been picked.

Geez, I'm sorry Common Thrill didn't win, dude. But get real. My band are a bunch of nobodies, and nobody would have fixed jack shit for us.


I don't think your band is very good.

Brux's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

MrPEZ wrote:
My band are a bunch of nobodies, and nobody would have fixed jack shit for us.

This is true.... I kid, I kid. Congrats Pez!

terrible_buddhist's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

are you kidding me, there are 10's of people who would rig this for Halogen :)

If I where in one of the bands, I would certainly be saying, wtf...but I am really happy Pez & co won!

Stacy's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

Seriously. The band that was meant to win it did. Move on...

Craiglucantus's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

i think a lot of these contests really suck. its fun to submit, but its nothing to get emotional over.

i will say though that it def proves that if you have solid product you can win.
99% of the people that vote aren't snobby fans or musicians like most of us on here. the average fan must have been impressed.

i submit our music to ourstage.com all the time and am suprised how those contests turn out. but its still fun.
but... ourstage is free.


"what?"

deseeded's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

Chris, the reason you lose all the time is that no one knows where the name Craig came from. I'll shed some light on it for everyone.

The name Craig was chosen in recognition of a starving Canadian toddler that Chris rescued from the jaws of a ferocious baby seal. Chris heroically stole the menacing doe-eyed seal's baby-specific cudgel and smashed that 3 week old seal's head in with it. No doubt, that same club was used to slaughter scores of flannelled French-Canadian child prodigies.

Here's a photo of what Chris had to fight through to save Craig Saint Lucantus.

Lincoln's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

Childish
Rhythms
Approximating
Indigo
Girls

Linnea's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

no matter what they all say congrats!

Craiglucantus's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

thanks linnea!

Norma Joy's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

First of all, cool to read that there are a lot of people out there thinking about stuff. To the person who wrote,” My band are a bunch of nobodies, and nobody would have fixed jack shit for us.” NO BAND IS A BUNCH OF NOBODIES!! All bands are somebodies, somebody somewhere knows who you are and appreciates what you do—busting your ass so you can do it too- No one creating should be down on himself. For those of you who wrote “These contests definitely have a stink of backroom political bullshit (I heard that WFNX is notorious for it),” and “There was definitely some weirdness going on. But it wasn't just the Boston contest that had the rules/voting/whatever changed mid-stream. There were simultaneous contests going on in 5 different markets, and they ALL changed in the exact same fashion,” THANKS! You made my point exactly. As for WFNX not having anything to do with it? Hmmm. If a radio station wants to promote a contest and get a lot of free publicity doing that, they should try to be fair to the hopeful musicians all of whom pulled out all the stops for this one. It wasn’t “Just fun to submit,” as one of you wrote. I mean come on! This ain’t just applause and a photo on stage at the Paradise, it’s a friggin’ deal with Capital Records!? And the host station should prove that they are worthy of the thousands—thousands of people, potential fans who went to the pages to vote. The radio station should check how the contest is being run. So sure “if you have solid product you can win,” if the contest is run fairly and I say “Rock on” to all 700 bands who threw their hats into the dreampot in the first place. Better Luck next time.

Sincerely,
A believer in fairplay

Lincoln's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

"NO BAND IS A BUNCH OF NOBODIES!! All bands are somebodies, somebody somewhere knows who you are and appreciates what you do—" Stuart Smalley

Brux's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

Wasn't the contest supposed to be that the top 3 would be finalists and the winner was chosen by Coldplay? So, you could potentially win so long as you placed in the top 3 regardless of having the most votes? This was my understanding.

I understand being sore about not winning, but geez.... I doubt seriously that the masons were behind this contest... still, where's my tinfoil hat?

MrPEZ's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

Brux wrote:
Wasn't the contest supposed to be that the top 3 would be finalists and the winner was chosen by Coldplay? So, you could potentially win so long as you placed in the top 3 regardless of having the most votes? This was my understanding.

I understand being sore about not winning, but geez.... I doubt seriously that the masons were behind this contest... still, where's my tinfoil hat?

Yes, that is how it worked. Except at the last minute, they changed it to the top 5, instead of the top 3. But they did that with the contests in Hartford & D.C. as well. Now, if the band that ultimately won had placed 4th or 5th in the voting, then this person would have a valid point. But that didn't happen.

Secondly, I don't think this person realizes that it's actually MY band that won the damn thing. So when I say "nobody would have rigged jack shit for us," that ain't just self-deprecation. It's because we don't know anybody at either Capitol or LiveNation, and neither organization would have ANYTHING to gain by steering things in our favor.

Jesus, I can't believe I even dignified this thread with a response...

Brux's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

But I hope that you realize now that you're somebody. You are a person of substance. Your band, too, has value.

MrPEZ's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

Brux wrote:
But I hope that you realize now that you're somebody. You are a person of substance.

Thank you for comforting me.

Brux wrote:
Your band, too, has value.

Just don't let Halogen know. Christ, I'd never hear the end of it.

Linnea's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

Yeah I guess I kinda phoned in that response, but either way I voted a few times and that's all that matters...
So how big is Halogen's head now?

HornResounding's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

I do like How Mr. Pez injected himself in the video. I think that when Coldplay saw that, they knew, no matter how rigged the contest was, The Luxury would prevail...

MrPEZ's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

HornResounding wrote:
I do like How Mr. Pez injected himself in the video. I think that when Coldplay saw that, they knew, no matter how rigged the contest was, The Luxury would prevail...

Yeah, congratulations on your first post, fake new persona.

MrPEZ's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

I'm fucking done with this bullshit.
Can you guys take care of this joker for me?

HornResounding's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

Ah yes, but the question is, whose fake persona? I'll give you a hint, I won the good sportsmanship in little league because i was so bad...

gaberollins's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

HornResounding wrote:
Ah yes, but the question is, whose fake persona? I'll give you a hint, I won the good sportsmanship in little league because i was so bad...

Diamond Dave? Is that you?

I can't believe David Lee Roth is on this website!

HornResounding's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

HUMMALABEEZAHUMMALABOP!

HornResounding's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

MrPEZ wrote:
I'm fucking done with this bullshit.
Can you guys take care of this joker for me?

I was trying to be nice and complimentary. I had thought the fix was in for the 4th or 5th place entry but obviously, that was not true. The Luxury won the contest simply because their entry was best. I watched all the videos and Malcontent was, IMHO, not only the best video but also the best song. I guess no good deed goes unpunished...

ECIchic's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

COME SEE THE LUXURY ON AUG 2ND AT THE LUCKY DOG!!!!!
THEY WILL BE PLAYING LATE SO COME ON DOWN, WISH THEM LUCK AND CONGRATS, AND WATCH THEM PLAY THEIR HEARTS OUT...
JAIME


A painter paints pictures on canvas. But musicians paint their pictures on silence.

MrPEZ's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

HornResounding wrote:
I was trying to be nice and complimentary. I had thought the fix was in for the 4th or 5th place entry but obviously, that was not true. The Luxury won the contest simply because their entry was best. I watched all the videos and Malcontent was, IMHO, not only the best video but also the best song. I guess no good deed goes unpunished...

I apologize, broham. Thought you were the same person who started this thread. I can't hold anything against anybody who took the time to type out the Diamond One's "Humalababalazebalahumalababalazebalabop."

Norma Joy's picture

Re:

No "Hornresounding" it wasn't the same person. And now I am yet another. The one concerned about the contest is a teacher. BTW-she doesn't even listen to rock music. Her students told her the contest was sketchy. She wanted to inspire people to think. Maybe some did. Seems to me she got more snipes, self-righteous defense and a dash of offense.

yeah "no good deed goes unpunished."

Norma Joy's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

Sorry this is confusing..guess it is MPez the post above should go to.

duncan's picture

Re: WFNX Coldplay Contest RIGGED!?

This thread is confusing and very silly. I am going to close comments on it but leave it here for people to read. Feel free to start a new thread if anyone wants to discuss making allegations in public forums on the internet and then being surprised when the public reads them.