Bands have to go through an awful lot of BS
sometimes to get thier big shot on the main stage.
Difficult bookers, bad sound guys the list goes on and on. Why do musicians put themselves through it all?
I asked myself this the other day and I came up with four reasons, prioritized:
1. To Get Exposure
I want my band to play in front of new faces. I am hoping that when I go into a club the club will have done it's work to bring folks into the club that my band has never played for before and in turn my band can give those heads the best possible show we can deliver. If the club is not going to provide new faces and I have to do all the footwork to get new faces in the door then why should I play at your shitty club? Why don't I just rent a hall and a soundsystem and do it myself?
2. To Meet New Good Bands From In Town And Out Of Town
I want to meet and play with like minded musicians because it is fun. I also want to play with bands from out of town to build friendships that stretch geographically so that my band can go to another town and...(see reason number one)
Again, if this cannot be provided for me then why should I play your shitty club? Why not just rent a hall, a sound system and bring in some great bands that I like?
3. I Want To Get Laid
Don't tell me that isn't the reason you picked up your instrument in the first place. To omit this from the list would be lying to myself and everyone else. If you can't get me laid then....
:)
4. I Want To Get Paid
In clubs this is of course hit or miss and I don't think any local musician living in reality expects to make any kind of real money. He does however expect to be paid fairly. Sometimes you play to quite a bit of people and walk away with about $40 for your efforts. Why should I play your club that is not providing my band with my number one and number two reasons for playing out for a measly $40. Especially when I can rent a hall, rent a soundsystem and book and promote the show how I see fit, myself?
On top of all these other things are intangibles that happen at your shitty club that I have no control over. Rude and unfriendly staff, poor parking, dirty restrooms, poor sound.
All of which I can oversee if I just rent out a hall, rent a sound system and book and promote my own damn show. Now why do I want to play at your shitty club again?
Comments
Re: Why do bands play in clubs?...
I enjoyed playing music because it was fun and I like rock and roll. I never really cared about obsessing over turning it into a business and trying every waking minute to maximize the $$ or exposure.
Getting laid? LOL. Never happened because of any band situation. I don't think it happens too much at all around here outside of a certain few people.
It doesn't help that there are about 20 single women in the music scene and 200 horny hairy rockers.
:-)
Re: Why do bands play in clubs?...
that is exactly how I came up with my unproven theory of the 10:1 ratio of men and women needed for a successful show. If I need 300 people at a show I do my best to get 30 mildy attractive women and the rest is easy.
www.duncanarsenault.com
Re: Why do bands play in clubs?...
Right and you found this out by playing and now you would rather just get together with friends and maybe bang on some stuff and really have no intrest in playing out, right?
Re: Why do bands play in clubs?...
Hey why can't I quote? (that last post was meant for Seekay)
Re: Why do bands play in clubs?...
No, I'd like to be in a band again someday, but I don't really have the time right now. It would have to be a low-maintenance thing.
Re: Why do bands play in clubs?...
I was going to hold my tongue but I couldn't help myself! The reality is if your not getting any action from playing in a band, either your band is terrible or you're just dang ugly or a combination of the two! Hey, at least you can work on the band part!
Re: Why do bands play in clubs?...
Worth reading...
http://cdbaby.org/stories/04/07/28/1978541.html
Your friend,
Craig
www.craig2000.com
"what?"
Re: Why do bands play in clubs?...
in the interest of calling a duck a duck, because no one gets up off their ass and completes any of their big plans to promote their own big rock show. it's easier to just call erick or vincent or whoever, because all that soundsystem and security and booze and shit is all in place.
these clubs have, either excellently or poorly, handled all of the details that everyone else gets lost in, or can't afford.
i get offers all the time from people who want me to design websites. it would be serious cash and there are some nifty big shortcuts i could take. but i don't, because i want to draw and paint and work on those skills, and i know i have no interest in any of the details involved with webdesign. am i happy with the sites that my logos and illos end up on? almost never. am i going to do it all myself? fuck no.
Re: Why do bands play in clubs?...
Derek, do those sites give you shit that you personally are not doing enough besides the making of said logo to bring the site more traffic? That's what my point of the article is. The clubs give you shit that isn't worth getting for what they provide for you and I am just wondering what is to gain for putting up with the shit.
You don't rent out a hall because you think that no one is gonna show besides your friends, but if you are going to have to be the one responsible for getting other people to show anyways, like the clubs seem to believe, why not just do it yourself anyways?
Re: Why do bands play in clubs?...
YES! last week was a nightmare, i got torn a new asshole by a person who didn't pay for the work i did for them. i suppose i should write an article. but i don't because it'll only ever been met with indifference. no one is going to feel sad for me.
and because you can't or won't. and they can bitch all they want, they own the club and are approached by a newspaper. you/we do not own a club, therefore we... post on message boards? hahaha. the reason they are asked what they think by a newspaper is because they are the centers of their music community, simply by virtue of stepping up, making the calls and signing the checks. shit, if they feel like it, they can say that the musicians need to wear uniforms and stand on their head onstage. it'd probably be pretty bad for business but it's within their prerogative to do so.
Re: Why do bands play in clubs?...
Despite some peoples frustration with this broken record. I for one never tire of discussing the possibilities that lie in Worcester MA. I don't think asking Huck and The Curtain Society to switch styles is the answer I personally was looking for, however I try to put those possibilities into action.
I hate to keep pushing these Networking Meeting but that is exactly what they are for. It is a time that we can take to put all of the words which are completely useless on their own and see them through. We have had booking agents and club owners at all of them so far. They are just there waiting to be talked to.
The internet is a great forum to hash out these ideas and get a consensus but in order for real change to occur people need to act.
Re: Why do bands play in clubs?...
That's all directly on point. I don't mean to dismiss this topic at all. What I am tiring of is the all talk, no action from some people.
The networking events, Volcanoboy's growth are evidence of NEW thinking and NEW energy coming into play.
Re: Why do bands play in clubs?...
There are men of ideas and there are men of action, and there are men of ideas and action. Everyone wants to at least be the idea guy. Folks seem to have a real problem taking an idea that is not theirs and going with it. I think it's human nature.
Re: Why do bands play in clubs?...
I have no problems stealing ideas from people who don't use them. A good idea is a good idea only if it is in action. I for one, think idea men are full of shit and need to get out of the way.
How about this for one-
I spent three years doing for the scene; hosting open mikes all over town, organizing and running the folk festival, going to Worcester rising meetings, helping organize the music at stART and it's fund raisers. You know what I found in doing all of that, frustration, exhaustion and my music was suffering for it. I made a conscience decision to stop all of that and focus my attention on the Bee's Knees and nothing else in the city. I say thins because what is lacking as well as all of the other things stated, are people who are involved that are not musicians. The Brian Goslows, Barry Dennis', Michael Creamers. Visual artists have Tina Zlody, what do musicians have? Yes, we have some people who host web sites which is very important now a days, but where are the folks that help with the promotion and help set up shows? My life would be a hell of a lot easier if I had someone to help with the non music issues.
By the way, I play in clubs because that is what I do. I have been a musicians for as long as I can rememebr and one of the venue for the music I play now is in rock clubs. If I was still conducting, I would be in concert halls and theaters. I'm a musician; I don't know anything else.
And the last reason I would ever be doing this is to get laid. I have never even had a girl apprroach me because I was a musician, let alone get laid because of it.
Re: Why do bands play in clubs?...
There appears to be no money in helping bands. that is what keeps the people away from doing things like that for bands. At least that is my guess.
Once anyones band begins to appear to be a money making opportunity you will see people come out of the woodwork.
Once in a while there are exceptions. People who believe in what you are doing and want to help. Those people are rare.
Also, say someone came along and wanted to do all the booking and promotion for you. They are successfully at it and you begin to sell out the 300person size clubs in the area.
How much are you paying them to do this?
Re: Why do bands play in clubs?...
I would like to think that I would be paying them the standard 12-15%, but I think you are right about the money. I guess I just get sick of all of this talk when I am busting my ass to promote, going to mixers and clubs to meet people and get people out. I know I am not the only one, but it just gets frustrating to hear people bitch about all of this stuff and take no action. It's kind of like bitching about politics and not voting; you have no right.
Re: Why do bands play in clubs?...
Here is one thought:
Band "A" draws an average of 40 people to a club
$5 a head x 40 = $200
Assuming this is the maximum amount of people that they can muster up themselves, consider this.
A promoter comes in and increases your average draw to triple. Say 120 people
$5 a head x 120 = $600
That is $90 for the promoter and $510 for the band that couldn't get more than 40 people to the show.
It is not a very appealing proposition.
Now granted, I side with the musicians making money. If a promoter is really good and well connected they dont have to do much work to get that $90 while the band has hours of work to put on that one show. But in Worcester, the amount of work needed to triple your draw is a hell of a lot of work isn't it?
I just thought I would share how that breakdown looks.
I am just making an observation.
Re: Why do bands play in clubs?...
Fair enough. I guess it comes down to the "love of the game" mentality that the musicians already have. Dickie seems like that kind of guy. I think he also enjoys how cool it is to be the manager of a band. Like all of us, he's an attention hound, but who isn't that is successful in this business?
Re: Why do bands play in clubs?...
Thank you, Barry. You said what I was trying to and you are that person we need (I don't mean you personally, but someone with your passion, not Passions like the show).
Re: Why do bands play in clubs?...
I never said there wasn't money in promoting. I said the opposite. A good promoter facilitates a successful show and reaps the reward. A lot of people win when it is done right. I think that the idea you will come across someone who just loves to do it and will do it effectively is wishful thinking. I find that wishfulness to be pervasive throughout the music scene. It comes down to what you really want. Do you want to play to more people? Have more people at your shows? or do you really want to make the money that would result?
Danimal makes money on the belief that you want to play to more people. He facilitates that very nicely.
Let's say that I was putting on a show. A guaranteed sellout at Ralph's, a few hundred people at least. I offered it to your band. The pay is $100.
Do you do it?
ps. 45 minute slot, no free beer and the drummer needs to keep his shirt on (if it's a female I will wave that)
Re: Why do bands play in clubs?...
Pay to play is tricky but in a way TCS did it for the "Soon" and "Anon" comps and CD release shows. I think the exposure was worth it in those cases for sure.
$100.00 to play ralphs for 300 people...not so much.
Now Lets say its a Metal/Hardcore show at the Palladium...10 bands, 30 min sets, all ages, doors at 5 show starts at six, random draw of who plays when. Maybe theres a "headliner" band as well...a well known boston or regional band. If I am the manager for Lucubro they pay $100.00 to do that show as long as they can sell merch and have an area to get names/e-mails/etc.
I know What I Like And I Like What I Know
Re: Why do bands play in clubs?...
Barry you might have been too busy shining your bag of Dice to read this but I said the pay is $100. Not, you pay me to play Ralph's.
It was hypothetical.
If a band said yes to that deal.
Which they should if they are not in a position to get 300+ people in front of them themselves.
They would in fact be paying a promoter far more than 15%.
Re: Why do bands play in clubs?...
Duncan...Oops. Sorry.
actually I was playing with my aquaman action figures(Yes thats plural)
Duncan...why can't I quote here?
Re: Why do bands play in clubs?...
the comments in news are not set up like a message board where you can easily quote the person above. You can view the thread in different ways (threaded, nested, flat) and some people prefer that. It is set to Flat right now. If you want to quote someone the best way to do it is press the
button and paste the text you want to quote. Like this....
Quote:
or this famous quote from you
Quote:
Re: Why do bands play in clubs?...
YOu know what Gabe, I have no good answer for you. We play Ralph's because we have done well there and we are treated well by the staff and Vincent and Dickie has been good to us so far, even though we have not really delt with him yet. We don't play the Lucky Dog very often because, while Erick treats us very well, his staff sucks and the sound usually sucks and we tend to bring in less people. I have never left Ralph's feeling like the door guy has screwed me,(I never did play there when Barry was running the door though) but I know I have been hosed at the Dog. To be honest, we have played shows that we have had to set up our own sound and while I don't mind (John does do most of the work!, ;-)) it really takes a toll on you, especially if you are playing for three hours or so. Maybe I am lazy. I guess that could be it. I need to think about this one...
Re: Why do bands play in clubs?...
I guess the title of this would have been better worded, "What do bands hope to gain by playing clubs."
If all you are out for is a good time on a Saturday night and your idea of a good time is playing to your friends about every six weeks than yeah, playing at those places is great, but what else does one hope to gain?
Re: Why do bands play in clubs?...
I would say no to Ralph's, but if you said Middle East Upstairs or TT's or at a number of clubs out of town, I would probably jump at that.
I agree, Duncan, it is wishfullness and that is why I never plan to have someone helping and, like every other band (or should be), am prepared to do it myself. I am also a control freak and have thought that if someone offered to take over these things, would I be able to trust them? At least now, I know things are getting done and if the ball gets dropped, it's my fault.
Did you ever feel like your brain is turning to mush?
Re: Why do bands play in clubs?...
As I stated once already my point was why do musicians play in clubs that don't give them ANYTHING in return except a place to play? Michael what are your reasons for playing out, yeah it is what you do, but why do you choose to play the places that you play and not play at say, Hokey's in Oxford?
Re: Why do bands play in clubs?...
Gabe...please don't take this the wrong way.
Why dont you take some CD'S from Michael, write up a cover letter( you are a good writer after all), send them out to places that you think they should play, and in your spare time, follow them up with phone calls or e-mails and get some shows for Bee's Knees.
Every month give the band a bill for your expences(phone,postage,copying etc.) and I am SURE they would reimburse you and probably throw a few extra dollars your way if you got them some paying gigs.
Re: Why do bands play in clubs?...
Duncan...if Danimal proved one thing it's that a promoter can make money.
I got involved with TCS/Ralphs/Bowlers years back because I felt passion for the music. I didn't know there was a "Scene" in fact I don't think there was one back then.
I have said this before, In the early 90's you didn't see members of the Curtain Society going to support Public Works or Black Rose Garden. Bonehead fans were not at Puddle shows. The exception was Roger because He produced a lot or bands.Bands were competitive with each other and I thought that was Great.
That drove me to work hard for the bands I promoted...Public Works headlined Ralphs on a weekend, well i am going to do whatever I need to so the Curtain Society can headline...and get paid more. Rose was on the cover of the Worcester Phoenix....I had to top that by getting a full color photo and a Feature story in the Worcester T+G. I promoted because I loved it and I was driven to do what I had to do to get the bands I worked for noticed.
IMO, there are people who could do a lot of good for bands, clubs, and music in general if they got off message boards and actually DID something and didn't worry about the money. Do it because you love it, do it because you want to see the music scene thrive.
I would do it again in a heartbeat if I felt the same Passion I feel for the Curtain Society for any other band but sadly I don't.